Friday, February 25, 2011

If you can't beat 'em.. join 'em - What I would do if I were the Cardinals GM

     About 48 hours ago the St. Louis Cardinals got some bad news. They learned that Adam Wainwright, their 20 game winner and runner up to Roy Halladay in the Cy Young voting, had significant pain in this throwing elbow. Not good. Fast foward to 24 hours ago, and Wainwright and the medical staff deemed that he go under season ending reconstructive surgery. This is about as bad as it gets for a team that looked like it was going for it this year and had a legitimate shot to possibly win a World Series.

     48 hours has gone by, and in that time I did some thinking as to what I would do if I were in charge of the baseball operations over in St. Louis. One thing that I can be certain of is that they are at the very definition of a cross roads. The situation they are in right now reminds me of where Milwaukee was when they traded for CC Sabathia and went for it all while they had a healthy (at the time) Ben Sheets and could contend for a title with a deadly 1 and 2 atop the rotation. Muck like Milwaukee, they face losing a very talented offensive player at first.

     The difference between the two however is that St. Louis has not totally gutted their farm system in the process. They have made some cost efficient moves that have made them competitive, but not desperate. By adding Lance Berkman, they have some protection for Matt Holliday and allow Colby Rasmus to hide in that threatening middle of the order. With the addition of a healthy David Freese, this team has plenty of offensive production to support what used to be a solid rotation. Now they lose Wainwright for 12-18 months assuming everything goes smoothely, and they face losing both Chris Carpenter and Albert Pujols to free agency in the off season. I think it's all but assumed that Carpenter will be signing elsewhere in the winter, and the Pujols situation has gone from bad to ugly. If the two of those players leave, it puts the Cardinals in a weird position because their offense will be average, and their pitching will lack both depth and quality. Jaime Garcia was good last year, but until he shows he can stay healthy and do it consistently, he's not considered more than a number three starter or an average number two.

     So here's an option that the Cardinals must, and most likely are considering: rebuild. This would mean trading Chris Carpenter and getting some value for him while he's still healthy and has a lot of potential return. If you do the deal now, you would get more in return because the team acquiring him would have a full season rather than less than half if it were at the trading deadline. If you move Matt Holliday also, you are freeing up a ton of money, and can start building around Colby Rasmus for the 2013 season when Wainwright returns from Tommy John. Let's face it, the Cardinals cannot make up for the (just over) 6 wins a game that Wainwright gives them according to WAR projections from FanGraphs. They have to do what's right for the organization and try to recoup some value while they still can.

Monday, January 24, 2011

The Wells, Rivera, Napoli deal and other notes

Alex Anthopoulos did what a lot of GM's and insiders didn't think was possible: Unload the massive Vernon Wells contract. Not only did he do so, he got two MLB-level talents in return. Toronto will save a ton of money in this deal, and it also allows them to balance their lineup better vs. tough lefties. Adam Lind has struggled against southpaws, and so has Travis Snider. This also buys them insurance in the case that JP Arencibia fails to live up to the hype over the course of a full big league season. Napoli has never been a great catcher, but he's serviceable and can play 1B and DH also. Rivera is nothing special, but he's serviceable and will benefit from being in a deeper lineup in Toronto.

As far as Wells, he will be an improvement over Rivera on both sides of the field. He had a resurgence in his numbers last year, but before that there were people talking about how he seems to throw away AB's and doesn't play his hardest all the time. Since that surfaced, Wells has shown an improvement and his power numbers returned. He will definitely benefit from being on a competitive team, and will fit nicely into the Anaheim lineup. However, with this all said, I do not feel that his overall value adds up to the cost associated. At his age, and the fact that he's already in the decline phase, Anaheim should have went and pushed harder to sign Carl Crawford. For a team that has been reported to be a little gun-shy for big contracts, this is a puzzling move and simply cannot come close to holding its value now and in the future. It's not even worth mentioning that Wells has an opt out clause after this season because there is no way he will ever see a contract like that ever again. Just when you give baseball ops people some credit for using their brains, they go and make moves like this that seem so blatantly one sided. It will be interesting to see what direction Toronto goes in, as Alex Anthopoulos has done a terrific job setting their club up from a talent and financial standpoint.


This comes a little late, but I am proud of Brian Cashman for coming forward and clearing his stance on the commitment to Rafael Soriano. I had actually discussed the fact that I thought he should do exactly that with a friend just two days before he stepped up and did so. It makes him look better, but in the end, a lot of GM's would give their first born son to have the advantages that come with being the Yankees GM.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Soriano gets 3yr/$35MM from Yankees

     In a day where relievers, and pitchers in general are throwing harder than ever with an even lower lifespan, the Yankees went out and spent big dollars on Rafael Soriano early this morning. The deal is worth a reported 3 years at $35MM in total contract value (plus some incentives I am sure). Immediately there was a bit of harsh reaction over the deal, and understandably so. Relievers don't live up to the multiple year deals that they frequently get when teams become desperate and/or victims of the current market. The Yankees front office can blame Detroit for the commitment they had to make to land Soriano. And although there is no chance he lives up to the full value of the contract, he acquisition has some implications that have become more and more obvious to even casual fans. The loss of a first round pick in the deepest draft in ages is a sign that the Yankees have no regard for getting the player they want.

     Although the deal is a bad one, it's not quite as bad as other writers have made it out to be. The easiest comparison I can make is Jonathan Papelbon. He is set to hit he open market next off season, and chances are that he will have a large check coming his way from some club. The Soriano deal will probably be the benchmark, but chances are his agent will push for more due to a healthy and successful track record. However, if you could pick between the two of them, who would you choose? I would pick Soriano. He has better stuff, he's shown he can transition from one league to another and have success in both. When he is healthy, he is flat-out dominant. Papelbon has shown a regression over the past two seasons in my opinino and scouting. His secondary stuff has never been above average, even below average. None of them lack depth or have particularly late movement. So in reality, if Soriano stays relatively healthy we may look back at the deal and think that the Yankees got a decent deal in the end. The easiest way of puting it is this: For the amount of dollars/years you are spending on depth guys and guys below the quality of Soriano, you must ask yourself (if you have the resources) how hard it is to get impact guys at the end of the bullpen. Soriano could easily close for NYY, and is probably an upgrade on 90% of closers presently in the position on other teams. Regardless of his title, he will provide solid innings and has shutdown stuff. The Yankees just told teams in the AL East that they have 7 innings to beat them.

Monday, January 10, 2011

Pavano back to the Twins; CarGo gets big extension; Note on Joakim Soria

Just before the weekend it became official that Carl Pavano was re-joining the Twins, in what looks to be a very competitive divsion this year. All of the teams in the central have improved, while the Twins are hopeful that Justin Morneau can return to his all-star caliber coming off of a concussion that took a serious toll on him for the entire second half of the 2010 season. Without Morneau, the Twins all but have no chance in the central this year. There is no way an opposing manager would let Joe Mauer beat them when the game is on the line, and who could blame them?

For the second time in the same offseason, the Colorado Rockies made a huge extension (and leap of faith) to 5-tool player Carlos Gonzalez for 7years and $80MM. This now locks up CarGo through arbitration and a couple of years afterwards. I think it's a great deal that reminds me of the deal Tampa Bay made with Evan Longoria. Now everyone who looks at that deal thinks Longoria was crazy, but Tampa saw a chance to lock up a player that is key to the success of their ballclub and they did it. Same with Gonzalez, because if 2010 isn't a fluke, they have possibly the best all-around player in the game locked up for cheap for the next 7 years. Even if he performs below 2010 (which he likely will), he will still be a great player to have because he does so many things on the field and he absolutely LOVES to hit in Coors Field. If Colorado is right, they will look like geniuses. If they are wrong, they will look like JP Ricardi did when he gave Alex Rios the mega-deal that made him borderline un-moveable. But even Rios had things to offer when he wasn't hitting, and eventually turned that around too.

I found a quote today on Buster Olney's blog about the position the Royals are in with Joakim Soria:

"3. Bill Madden doesn't get the Royals' stance on refusing to trade Joakim Soria. I'd respectfully disagree: Soria's contract is so extraordinary for the team that the value of his deal makes it almost impossible for Kansas City to get equal value."

I completely disagree with Buster on many levels. First of all Soria is cheap, but to Kansas City, that money is better off investing in young position players who will set you up for years of production. Rarely do closers hold their value. Also, closers do not draw fans into the ballpark. I wouldn't pay $100 to watch a team of prospects never get a lead enough times to watch Soria pitch. The fact that his contract is so attainable is even more valuable due to the fact that many mid to low market teams could get involved and not have to move money to take him on, just talent. When they traded Greinke (a guy that draws fans) and now refuse to trade Soria (a guy who throws a couple innings a week) it's really sending mixed signals to the fans in KC. However, I doubt they are thinking along the same lines as everyone in the media. They are smart baseball minds, and realize all of these things also. I wouldn't be shocked at all if Tampa Bay went out and got him with some of the pieces they picked up in the Matt Garza trade.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Texas to acquire Beltre, DH Young

The baseball front offices must have been skeptical of Adrian Beltre, and rightly so. His career has been like many others to come down the baseball chain. One of great promise, incredible athletic ability, but an annoying inability to perform consistently. It is quite possible that playing in Safeco field had a great impact on his power numbers while playing in Seattle, and it's also possible that he was likely injured and played through it. But, one cannot bring up Adrian Beltre and think "yikes" when they look at his career track record compared to his contract years. The incredible thing that I always bring up when the subject of "contract year" comes up, is that it is mind boggling that these athletes are so talented that they can just simply turn it up a notch on their performance when a pay raise is in line. We see it time and time again, and you never hear about the guys who play hard every day and produce regardless of their contract.

Beltre is the best defensive third baseman in baseball. Advanced stats will tell you, and your eyes will too. For a guy of his size, he seems to always have his body in the right place at the right time to make the play, and make it look effortless. His defensive metrics have never been in question to anybody. His play at the plate during his contract year with the Dodgers and the Red Sox were awe inspiring MVP-caliber. Last year in Boston, Beltre showed that he's not just a power hitter when he's on.. but he can also hit for a high average and get on base. When he hits the ball, he hits it really hard. One of the most talked about things is when he drops to his knees while hitting a moon shot over the green monster. The way he is able to do things like that and still generate solid contract and leave his bat in the zone for so long is impressive. He isn't your 3-hole hitter, but he is a great 4 or 5 hitting behind a lefty, ala Josh Hamilton. With the kind of skillset that Beltre has, you can't blame a team like Texas locking him down and making room for him on the roster. The deal is a big long for a player at his age, but chances are he will hold his value relatively deep into the contract assuming he stays healthy.

The one thing that bothers me about the deal is the position that Michael Young is currently in. I am of a strong opinion that using him at DH is not using him at peak value. Although he is no longer a plus defender, he is capable and can play many positions. I do not like the idea of using him as a super-utility, because again, this means that an every day player is sitting or DH'ing to make room. There is no doubt that Vlad is getting old and losing bat speed, but I would rather trade Young now to a team that needs a player who can impact their lineup and sign Vlad on the cheap. They would not be losing a draft pick, and what they get in return for Young could set them up to acquire a starter, which they desperately need. I'm not totally sold on Neftali Feliz transitioning into the rotation and being dominant. He has very high expectations (and rightly so), but it was out of the bullpen where hitters aren't going to see you more than once.

I have a hunch that Carl Pavano will be heading to the Yankees again. It makes too much sense, for both parties. I also hope that Joe Girardi opens his eyes and sticks Robinson Cano into the 3-hole, followed by A-Rod and then Teixeira. This is Robinson Cano's team now that Jeter and A-Rod are showing signs of age.

Friday, December 10, 2010

What the Crawford signing means to the AL East

            The balance of power in the AL East seemed to swing late Wednesday night, as the Red Sox and Carl Crawford made an announcement that they had agreed to a 7-year/$142MM contract pending a physical. From what I understand, Crawford's decision was based upon the players attitudes towards the game. The tough nosed, gritty style of play that the likes of Dustin Pedroia, Kevin Youkilis, Jason Varitek and others. That is an uncommon thing to come from a player regarding why he chose a certain place to play, and a good one for Red Sox fans. There are intangibles that go with certain guys, and they can be infectious. Not only does Crawford bring his rare and unique skill set to a team that had been getting progressively older and slower, he brings an attitude that will make everyone around him better.

             From seeing Crawford over the years, I can tell you that he is a special player. The amazing part is that even though most others in New England have seen him and how he plays the game, they were still sort of enamoured over Jayson Werth because of his power/RBI potential. Most used the argument that none of his stats (aside from the obvious steals) jump out at you, and how could he possibly be worth $20MM/season? If you were to look deeper however, there is really no comparison between the two. There are aspects to total production that put miles between the two of them. For those who do not really understand the difference, an easy way is to look at a typical fantasy league and use a player comparison to see the intricacies. Amazingly, Crawford had 5 more RBI (90) than Werth (85). Werth was higher in slugging, walks, doubles and HR's with 46 less AB's. Seems like I don't know what I'm talking about, right? Not so fast.

           Werth was the crucial right handed compliment to the Phillies lineup. He saw an incredibly better amount of RBI situations and better pitches to hit. He hit in a ballpark that is made for him, and is an injury risk. He also has only had two years of real evidence that he can put up these kind of numbers. Numbers which did not start to surface until he was mixed in the Philly lineup, and in that ballpark. Crawford has hit in many different spots in the lineup, and used in different ways than Werth. His consistent production is something you can contribute to his hard work ethic. Now he will no longer be the man along with Evan Longoria, he will be mixed into an all-star lineup that will be relentless against RHP. He will likely see an incredible amount of better pitches to hit due to the mix of players hitting behind him, no matter where he hits in the lineup. He has less holes in his swing, and is more likely to hold his value through the end of this deal than Werth.
            One thing to watch now that the Red Sox lineup got even more left handed is the value of Brian Fuentes and Scott Downs. It is almost a certainty that they will be given a bigger deal than they had anticipated with the Yankees now in more need of their services. Word is that Damaso Marte will not be healthy enough to start the season, and even he is climbing in age. Both Downs and Fuentes have shown that they can get righties out, but if I had to choose between the two I would go with Downs. He has a variety of off-speed stuff that I think would play better in Yankee stadium in terms of giving up the long ball. They are both very effective against left-handed batters and one of them is almost certain to sign with NYY.

           The Cliff Lee saga continues, as both the Rangers and Yankees dig a hole deeper than they would like. It's really sad, because at 7-years, one of these teams are going to likely regret overextending themselves. However, I have written previously that I feel that Lee will age well. He has always been able to locate and aside from the mistake to Edgar Renteria, he rarely makes mistakes that hurt him. His WHIP over the past 4 seasons is astounding. The most exciting thing to consider is what all this means to Albert Pujols. The best hitter in the game must be watching this very closely. As Bobby Cox was quoted as saying "if Ryan Howard gets $25MM/year, then Pujols should get $50MM/year because he is twice as good as anybody out there".

Monday, December 6, 2010

Sox acquire Gonzalez, other moves as the Winter Meetings begin

The Boston Red Sox put together the final touches on a trade that had been in the works for over two years to acquire 1B Adrian Gonzalez. Gonzalez is an extremely talented hitter that should have no problem adjusting to the AL East due to his plate recognition and ability to work with a pitch rather than force it. He has been scouted as to have issues with inside fastballs, but this should be an adjustment he can make rather easily without having to cheat too much. He lets the ball travel very deep into the strike zone and seems to really see the ball, and rarely overswings. He is a rarely gifted lefty, in that he handles left handed pitching rather well. Despite playing in one of the most pitcher friendly parks in baseball, he has managed to put up both power and average numbers consistently since being dealt to San Diego from Texas. Gonzalez had his $6.5MM option picked up by San Diego previous to dealing him to Boston, and weather or not that contract will be erased by a new 7-year/$154MM deal is yet to be seen. As of the time of this writing, Gonzalez has not put the pen to paper on a new deal. Rumors are that him and the team have agreed to wait until after the first game of the season to avoid an extended luxury tax penalty. The rumor that the Red Sox ownership are trying to do this in order to spend more money on free agents this offseason is laughable. If they want somebody they will go get the player if they feel it is within reason and value, regardless if they save a couple million in luxury tax penalties.

Out the door to San Diego are three top flight talents from the Red Sox system. Kelly, Rizzo and Fuentes who have yet to see MLB action, thus their countdown to a raise has yet to begin. This was very important, and the difference between Fuentes and Ellsbury being the players swapped. Even if San Diego had coveted Ellsbury, he is about to hit his arbitration years and is expeted to get a hefty couple of raises. He is also represented by Scott Boras, and judging by how grossly overpaid Jayson Werth just got via free agency and an open market, you can guarantee that Ellsbury will be doing exactly the same about 3 or 4 years from now. There are may scouting reports available for all three of these players available, so I won't go into major detail about them. However, Kelly will substantially benefit from playing in Petco Park. That is something that I wrote about previous to Jason Stark's tweet that surfaced up today as Gonzalez was officially introduced. Seeing as how Kelly was made available recently to San Diego, I think that once he was able to be had that SD had to make the move. They received a significant offer from CHW, and I am assuming that Tyler Flowers was part of the deal, possibly Chris Sale also came up in discussions. Judging by the fact that AJ Pierzynski was resigned by CHW, I think that the ChiSox may be losing faith in Flowers as a big league backstop and SD most likely saw the same thing.


Later on this afternoon I learned that Mark Reynolds was traded to Baltimore for pitchers David Hernandez and Kam Mickolo. Hernandez is the most polished of the two, and had some success as a closer/setup man for Baltimore after being bumped out of the rotation. He has good movement on his fastball and mixes in a slider to keep hitters off balance. I have been hearing that ARZ will use him in a relief role, where his stuff tends to be more sharp and he is more effective when he is not going through the lineup three to four times a game. Mickolo is the guy with the bigger stuff, but less command and polish. He has had a tough time in the AL East, but what pitcher doesn't at some point? He will certainly have a better time getting by hitters in the weakest division in baseball, but watch out for the long ball.

Baltimore now gets the corner infielder with power that they lost when Aubrey Huff left to the champion San Francisco Giants. Between losing Huff and most likely Ty Wiggington, they looked to get some of those RBI's back with a gamble. I am not under the impression that this will work out however, and think Baltimore should have folded this hand and kept onto their live arms. Simply put: Reynolds will be overmatched in the AL East.

Hot stove is burning at the moment, rumor is that a possible Greinke deal could net KC a huge return. Rumor was that they asked for Kyle Drabek. Travis Snider and two prospects from Toronto in return for Greinke. That would be essentially Roy Halladay and Travis Snider for Greinke.. doesn't sound so good if you're a Jays fan when you put it that way.